"Six stars will fall to this plane. The dark stars that will defy the heavens…"- a RG Veda review

From left to right: Ashura, Yasha-ou, Souma-ou, Ryou-ou, Kendappa-ou, Karura-ou

From left to right: Ashura, Yasha-ou, Souma-ou, Ryou-ou, Kendappa-ou, Karura-ou

    A 10-volume manga series by CLAMP, notable for being their debut work, and named after the ancient Hindu hymn collection the Rigveda. The series borrows elements of Hindu and Buddhist mythology for its setting and characters.
300 years ago, the general Taishakuten rebelled against the Heavenly Emperor, killing both him and the guardian god Ashura-ou and installing himself as the king. The Ashura clan was thought to be destroyed until the god Yasha-ou found the remaining child sealed in a forest and began to gather the Six Stars, a group of individuals said to be the prophecied bringers of a celestial revolution.

From left to right: Ashura, Yasha-ou, Souma-ou, Ryou-ou, Kendappa-ou, Karura-ou

From left to right and from bottom to the top: Ashura, Yasha-ou, Ryou-ou, Souma-ou, Kendappa-ou, Karura-ou

Back then CLAMP consisted out of 7 members. It started with 11 and ended up with the fabulous max quartet as we know it today. RG Veda is almost a manifesto of the art quality the quartet produces and the themes CLAMP love to talk about: Mokona’s style gets established, a definite bishoujo-bishounen eye candy; and wishes for which individuals go to limits (see Taishakuten and TRC’s Syaoran), dangerous wishes that come at a cost (see Ashura-ou and the customers from xxxholic), fate can be changed (see the end of the manga as well as TRC), loves of all forms (see shounen-ai between Taishakuten and Ashura-ou, shoujo-ai between Shouma and Kendappa, filial love between Gigei and Ashura, – CCS offers even more), mirroring and duality (see Ashura and Kujaku, later in X to a maximum), eye fetish (here we are presented with an extra, third, eye, but usually we get an eye less…), multiple twists are indicators you are reading a CLAMP work.

“In the beginning we had a hard time balancing out the comedic aspect with the serious side of the story”

“In the beginning we had a hard time balancing out the comedic aspect with the serious side of the story”

Lastly there are some plot holes that bothered me much, for example Ryu-ou’s role in the story (was he simply a comedic relief or the bubbly persona or even just one extra person to fill in the prophesized number of Stars?) and how everything progressed from sad to tragic, maybe only for drama’s shake (why couldn’t CLAMP find a more peaceful way to resolve things? Were all the massacres really needed?). As a debut work had some flaws, like awkward lines and dialogues – CLAMP obviously have some regrets about this part and they would do it very differently, if they could now.

Character development was superficial due to the short time span of the story and the lack of more slice-of-life moments. I refer mainly to Yasha’s and Ashura’s feelings for each other that seem to grow strong and fast without much reasoning. Kendappa-ou’s personality is one that stands apart from the rest for its multiple layers that lead to the weirdest decisions and probably for her being equally hated and admired by fans. The problem with her is for me her no-ground conviction of with whom she sides with.

pages from vol.2 and vol.5 respectively

pages from vol.2 and vol.5 respectively

In spite of all its flaws, RG Veda is one of those manga that you can’t leave from hands until you reach the last page. There are plenty pretty characters to choose from as your favorite one and sympathetic pairs to root for. My favs are the dynamic and beautiful lesbians, Kendappa x Souma, the sweet Shara x Rasetsu and the main pair of Ashura x Yasha which here is presented with familial tones rather than erotic ones as seen in TRC (hm…aren’t they better in TRC? ). All in all, RGVeda isn’t a bad read, but if you search for deeper meanings, plots that make more sense or something not plagued by successive disasters and deaths, I wouldn’t recommend it. Generally if you aren’t a CLAMP fan addicted to shoujo prettiness and you don’t have time to kill, you wouldn’t be interested. I think there are manga that in every section could outdo this work.

little Ashura and awakened God of Destruction

little Ashura and awakened God of Destruction

There is a 2-episode OVA that naturally doesn’t cover the whole story and from the reviews I’ve seen around the net, it isn’t a material worth watching. The narration starts in media-res and anyone who hasn’t read the manga is at lost at what’s going on.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “"Six stars will fall to this plane. The dark stars that will defy the heavens…"- a RG Veda review

  1. I was obviously lured into this manga by Kendappa and Souma. The problems were:
    1: I watched the 2-OVAs first, which was a terrible manga lure and KendOuma hardly got any screen time together.
    2: I Wiki’d Kendappa and Souma…and was irritated. Seriously, I can’t stand indecisive/double agent tramps like her.

    Oh well. As far as Clamp goes, I’ll always have wonderful memories of Magic Knight Rayearth. Season 1 anyway. Season 2 was mediocre to average.

    P.S.: The required age of an adult is 30, not 21. 21 is a young adult.

    Like

    • I can see why someone may hate Kendappa and I did at first, too. Yet she is quite intriguing and I wish we could see more into her psyche.

      I need to watch MKR season 2, so that I can review the series and the manga. It’s a good work, but it gets repetitive at some parts, and since I watched it as an adult, I couldn’t honestly enjoy it.

      P.S.: a young adult is still an adult who makes political and financial choices on his/her own.

      Like

  2. @Kencana: First of all, how would we have a story, if someone doesn't go against fate? Secondly, vanity. Gods are a lot like humans. They still want to pursue a certain path even with knowing beforehand the consequences. I guess, he didn't want not to become a father. He wanted to be the one who'll defy fate.

    Like

  3. Just like you said, there's some plot hole. If Ashura-ou know that his son will bring destruction, why he bother married and get child at first place? Can you please explain to me?

    Thank you.

    Like

  4. @marinasauce: First works can't be perfect I guess, but they are still interesting to study to search for ideological and interest changes of the mangaka over time.

    I agree with you on your remarks about a quality dip in terms of stories, but let's hope Gate 7 can redeem them. As you've probably read from the introductory post, I wasn't that pleased with Blood-C and Kobato. There's also the issue of repetitive design and themes that start getting a bit stale.

    CLAMP are generally admirable for sacrificing their personal lives and producing so many works over the span of 20 years. Some times even working on multiple series simultaneously! And for creating works that reach wide audiences.

    As for my favorite works of theirs, you'll most probably understand it without me saying anything while the project unfolds. I don't want to spoil the fun 🙂

    Like

  5. I find it so fascinating to see where CLAMP originated from and hear your thoughts on their first work. I greatly admire CCS, xxxHOLiC, and TRC, but have found their more recent involvements somewhat less enjoyable and coherent. In terms of quality, for me at least, it looks a bit like a parabola.

    Like

Take your pen and write your story, co-traveler~

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s